2 scenes compared. Meaning?

Started by BikerDude, May 09, 2014, 03:28:30 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

BikerDude

What with all of the comparing the Dude to Jesus and Donnie to Jesus and the walrus to.. lost my train of thought.
I'm wondering how these 2 well known scenes taken together may or may not lend meaning to one another.

Scene  1.
Quote
DUDE
            You thought Bunny'd been kidnapped
            and you could use it as a pretext to
            make some money disappear.  All you
            needed was a sap to pin it on, and
            you'd just met me.  You thought,
            hey, a deadbeat, a loser, someone
            the square community won't give a
            shit about.

                  LEBOWSKI
            Well?  Aren't you?

                  DUDE
            Well. . . yeah.


Scene 2

Quote
                  THE STRANGER
            I don't know about you, but I take
            comfort in that.  It's good knowin'
            he's out there, the Dude, takin' her
            easy for all us sinners. 

Discuss amounst yourselves...


Out here we are all his children


DigitalBuddha

Quote from: BikerDude on May 09, 2014, 03:28:30 PM
What with all of the comparing the Dude to Jesus and Donnie to Jesus and the walrus to.. lost my train of thought.
I'm wondering how these 2 well known scenes taken together may or may not lend meaning to one another.

Scene  1.
Quote
DUDE
            You thought Bunny'd been kidnapped
            and you could use it as a pretext to
            make some money disappear.  All you
            needed was a sap to pin it on, and
            you'd just met me.  You thought,
            hey, a deadbeat, a loser, someone
            the square community won't give a
            shit about.

                  LEBOWSKI
            Well?  Aren't you?

                  DUDE
            Well. . . yeah.


Scene 2

Quote
                  THE STRANGER
            I don't know about you, but I take
            comfort in that.  It's good knowin'
            he's out there, the Dude, takin' her
            easy for all us sinners. 

Discuss amounst yourselves...

My first thought is that, like all dudes, we are a mass of contradictions.

Caesar dude

So would any of you dudes actually pay a girl for sex?
Love is like a butterfly it goes where it pleases and it pleases where it goes. :)

DigitalBuddha

Quote from: Caesar dude on May 11, 2014, 01:13:21 AM
So would any of you dudes actually pay a girl for sex?

Never buy a drink you can enjoy for free. 8)

Caesar dude

"Raises sunglasses" I'll just find a cash machine...... :)
Love is like a butterfly it goes where it pleases and it pleases where it goes. :)

jgiffin

I need a hint. I don't see any connections between the two short excerpts.

If I were batshit crazy, I'd try to make something of the reference to "sin" and the phrase "sap to pin". If you juxtapose the first letters of the primary words in the latter phrase, you get "pap sin". Clearly, the Cohen Bros. are making a statement about the underlying dangers of rampant female (i.e., strongly vaginal) sexuality in the post-modern era. The Bible (in Romans 6:23) foresaw that women would bear the wages of their sins by subjecting themselves to invasive pap smears testing for loathsome diseases.

But, I mean, other than that axiomatic parallel I don't get it.

BikerDude

#6
Quote from: jgiffin on May 13, 2014, 11:08:47 PM
I need a hint. I don't see any connections between the two short excerpts.

If I were batshit crazy, I'd try to make something of the reference to "sin" and the phrase "sap to pin". If you juxtapose the first letters of the primary words in the latter phrase, you get "pap sin". Clearly, the Cohen Bros. are making a statement about the underlying dangers of rampant female (i.e., strongly vaginal) sexuality in the post-modern era. The Bible (in Romans 6:23) foresaw that women would bear the wages of their sins by subjecting themselves to invasive pap smears testing for loathsome diseases.

But, I mean, other than that axiomatic parallel I don't get it.

Speaking to the possibility that "Takin her easy" might leave us vulnerable to such manipulation.
Sinner as in that double crossing paraquat the big L. (Or whoever might wish to exploit the Dudely)
What utility does "Takin her easy" offer in respect to all us sinners?
How does it serve sinners?
If it's a sort of Jesus Christ reference like "died for our sins" then it does imply something like a martyrdom.

Assuming that the Dude is correct and the Big L was playing him then he must have been testing the Dude with..

Quote
                                                LEBOWSKI
            It's funny.  I can look back on a
            life of achievement, on challenges
            met, competitors bested, obstacles
            overcome.  I've accomplished more
            than most men, and without the use
            of my legs.  What. . . What makes a
            man, Mr. Lebowski?

                  DUDE
            Dude.

                  LEBOWSKI
            Huh?

                  DUDE
            I don't know, sir.

                  LEBOWSKI
            Is it. . . is it, being prepared to
            do the right thing?  Whatever the
            price?  Isn't that what makes a man?

                  

In this context the Big L doesn't believe that "doing the right thing" amounts to jack shit.
He's ready to be a dick if it serves his needs. And he's planning on fucking over the Dude.
He's a sinner. Doesn't care about doing the right thing.
He is wondering if the Dude feels that way. 'ie' looking for a Sap to pin it on.
He thinks  "challenges met, competitors bested, obstacles overcome" is what makes a man.
He's proud to not do the right thing when it serves his needs if it helps him best competitors and overcome obstacles.(Of course he is a gold bricking phoney and human paraquat)

Now how does the Stranger chime in on this?
Says he takes comfort in knowing he's out there. For us sinners.
How does the Dude serve sinners by abiding and takin' her easy?




Out here we are all his children